Excerpts and Opinions on “What Makes a Hospital Great?”

March 17th, 2011 by Nick Jacobs Leave a reply »

Dr. Pauline W. Chen’s March 17th New York Times article answers the question, “What Makes a Hospital Great?” In this article, Dr. Chen finds:

Dr. Pauline W. Chen - surgeon & New York Times contributor - Nick Jacobs, FACHE

Pauline W. Chen, MD | Blog: paulinechen.typepad.com

“Hospitals have long vied for the greatest clinical reputation. Recent efforts to increase public accountability by publishing hospital results have added a statistical dimension to this battle of the health care titans. Information from most hospitals on mortality rates, readmissions and patient satisfaction is readily available on the Internet. A quick click of the green ‘compare’ button on the ‘Hospital Compare’ Web site operated by the Department of Health and Human Services gives any potential patient, or competitor, side-by-side lists of statistics from rival institutions that leaves little to the imagination. The upside of such transparency is that hospitals all over the country are eager to improve their patient outcomes. The downside is that no one really knows how.”

I’ve written often about the failed promise of technology alone, and this is reaffirmed in Dr. Chen’s findings:

“…hospitals have made huge investments in the latest and greatest in clinical care — efficient electronic medical records systems, ‘superstar’ physicians and world-class rehabilitation services. Nonetheless, large discrepancies persist between the highest and lowest-performing institutions, even with one of the starkest of the available statistics: patient deaths from heart attacks.”

As she asks why this is,  the answers have become relatively clear from a study that was released in the Annals of Internal Medicine this very week. This research indicated that it was not the expensive equipment, the evidence-based protocols, or the beautiful Ritz Carlton-like buildings. It was, instead, the culture of the organization.

Hosptials in both the top and bottom five  percent in heart attack mortality rates were queried by the study team. One hundred fifty interviews with administrators, doctors and other health care workers found that the key to good (or bad) care was “a cohesive organizational vision that focused on communication and support of all efforts to improve care.”

Elizabeth H. Bradley, Phd, Yale School of Public Health

Elizabeth H. Bradley, Phd, Yale Global Health Leadership Institute

“It’s how people communicate, the level of support and the organizational culture that trump any single intervention or any single strategy that hospitals frequently adopt,” said Elizabeth H. Bradley, Senior Author and Faculty Director of Yale University’s Global Health Leadership Institute.

So, it wasn’t the affiliation with an academic medical center, whether patients were wealthy or indigent, bed size, or rural vs. urban settings that mattered in hospital mortality rates. Rather, it was the way that patient care issues were challenged that made the difference. The physicians and leaders at top-performing hospitals aggressively go after errors. They acknowledge them, and do not criticize each other. Instead, they work together to identify the sources of problems, and to fix them.

One of the most telling findings in this study was that relationships inside the hospital are primary, and the physicians and staff must be committed to making things work. Dr. Bradley said. “It isn’t expensive and it isn’t rocket science, but it requires a real commitment from everyone.”

So, the next time that you select a hospital, look up its statistics, and I guarantee you that you will be surprised. When it comes to outcomes, to nurturing or even competent care, the biggest is not always the best.

Learn More:

Advertisement

10 comments

  1. When you go in search of honey you must expect to be stung by bees.

  2. Great post, I want thank to author becaus i’ve read here a lot good knowledge. Keep it going! :) . Best regards

  3. For such a good post, Im pretty dissapointed at the quality/quantity of comments.

  4. Allie Cooper says:

    Nicely… to become fully honest, I failed to be prepared to discover this sort of information by chance, as I did so, because I just discovered this web site even though I was actually conducting research online in the search engines, searching for some thing extremely close however, not very the same… On the other hand right this moment I am just over thrilled to always be below and I would really like to include that your standpoint can be remarcable despite the fact that the trifle questionable to my own taste… I would alternatively say it should be around debate… yet Now i’m afraid to make you an opponent, haya, ha, ‘… At any rate, in case you want to speak in greater detail regarding it, you need to reply to our opinion along with I will be sure to join to ensure that I will be informed and also come back for additional…

  5. Marni Bretz says:

    An impressive share, I just supplied this onto a colleague who was executing somewhat examination on this. And he in reality purchased me breakfast like a result of I found it for him.. smile. So enable me reword that: Thnx with the deal with! However yeah Thnkx for spending the time to discuss this, I really really feel strongly about it and love browsing a lot more on this matter. If doable, as you alter into encounter, would you thoughts updating your weblog with excess details? It is hugely useful for me. Major thumb up for this weblog submit!

  6. prayer says:

    I believe other word wide web site proprietors should take on this internet site as an model, really clean and good user pleasant fashion and style, likewise as the information. That you are an specialist in such a subject!

  7. Nokia huolto says:

    For me an ideal hospital has a good doctor and not late cause in some place the doctors are always late and the patient are always waiting.In Finland where i live and working in a Nokia service i can say the our hospital are doing a very good job cause they are doing their promise to help people and the fact that doctor are always on time?

  8. extremists en route for any thrust homespun the perspective or even claim that everyone else from the world is located sin against. thank on your to the point as well as related understanding.

  9. I am curious to find out what blog platform you’re using?
    I’m having some minor security issues with my latest website and I would like to find
    something more safeguarded. Do you have any recommendations?

    Look into my web blog :: http://tinyurl.com/n77d7zn

  10. Tia says:

    This design is wicked! You definitely know how to keep a reader entertained.
    Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to
    start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent job.
    I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it.
    Too cool!

    Here is my blog … website – Tia,

Leave a Reply