Making Sense of Tucson

January 11th, 2011 by Nick Jacobs Leave a reply »

It was 1991 when one of  my professors at Carnegie Mellon University began discussing health policy in the United States.  He told us about Arizona, where the state government had decided to stop paying for transplants.  Then he went on to explain that desperate families were moving from Arizona to Pittsburgh, just so they could establish residency in Pennsylvania, and their loved one could receive a transplant.

At around that same time, an outspoken politician from Colorado, former Governor Richard Lamm, who ran for President of the United States on the Reform Party, described the travesty of Medicare vs. Medicaid.   He described the older generation as committing “generational murder” because, even though many times there was no hope  for their survival, for extending their life or for having any quality to their life, we, as a nation, spend 60% of our Medicare dollars on the last  30 or so days of life.  He advocated being honest and allowing people to decide if they wanted palliative care.

What he also pointed out was that, as a country, we continue to have one of the highest infant mortality rates in the industrial world. The reason, he theorized, was because the seniors voted and the young mothers didn’t and no politician would dare vote against that senior coalition.  (This is not about death panels, it is about honesty in healthcare. It is about transparency and explaining the facts to the families so that they could make rational decisions.) None of his words were well received, but nevertheless, they were filled with candor and embraced very difficult ethical views.

Giffords Tucson tragedy - Nick Jacobs, FACHE - Healing Hospitals

The bottom line?  It is a very sad situation when we have to, in effect, sentence people to death at any age because resources are not available to save them, but this is emphatically not about rationing of care, because rationing infers giving everyone a little less.  This is about making a government decision to take away everything. So, this is about making rational  resource allocation, not based upon the number of votes needed to get re-elected, but based on the value of a life at any and all ages.

Finally, the elephant in the room?  Those people killed and wounded in Arizona were killed and wounded because of a man who is most likely mentally ill.  We, as a country, must begin to address this mental health issue with parity, with commitment and without judgment.  No family is without some member who is suffering from some mental health issue, but  this discussion is still ignored, hidden or buried.

So, when the pundits ask if it is about the rhetoric? We don’t know. When they ask if it is about the availability of weapons and ammunition?  The answer seems to fall under that same category. BUT, when the question is properly directed toward mental health?  The answer seems to be absolutely, yes without a doubt.

During this time of reflection, let’s get serious about the very real and very big challenges that this nation faces. We must, as a nation, take these challenges head-on and deal with “problem solving,” and if this Congress does not begin to take action and begin to solve problems, then we must vote again in May and November to continue to make our voices heard.

Unless we can begin to talk with each other with dignity and respect, we will not make progress.  Until we begin to respect the other person’s point of view and understand that debates are healthy again, we will not make progress. Our leaders need to debate, but at the end of that debate, it is essential that they walk out of the room together and agree that they are all here to do a job, and that job is to solve problems.

My heart goes out to all of those families who were impacted by this awful tragedy.



  1. Kristina says:

    it’s a tragedy… my prayers are with these families.

  2. Nick, your analysis has steered the right path by avoiding the supposed political aspects of this tragedy, which many early commentators reflexively assumed were at its core.

    Now, we learn that Mr. Loughner’s mental health issues are indeed central to the case. Shockingly, we also learn that at least one outspoken, partisan, public figure may bear significant responsibility for apparently ignoring his office’s knowledge of the suspect’s lengthy, prior history of making death threats, while falsely assuring victims that Loughner was “being well managed by the mental health system.”

  3. Karen West says:

    You are so to the point, Mr. Jacobs. We cannot address a problem if we cannot accept and acknowledge that it does exist.

    As a nation, we must agree to “respectfully disagree” and not try to solve our problems with tantrums, weapons or blame.

    Thank you for sharing your insight.


    in Tucson

  4. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!

  5. Frankly speaking, I found your site really “hygienic”. With the term “hygienic”, I struggle to emphasis that we share one common taste. The goodness of your blogposts has refueled my dormant soul. I really could not help but bookmark your web site. Hope your forthcoming articles will probably be interesting too.

  6. I really enjoy reading your blog articles your amazing way to see things is what keeps me fascinated. I suggest, you could include more topics about health care for example infectious diseases Thanks so much!!!!

  7. It is a very sad situation when we have to, in effect, sentence people to death at any age because resources are not available to save them

  8. Great web site!.. You must include this site on a free directory is really helpful, maybe you could include more articles about Panic Attack Recommendations and others diseases.

  9. Daniell Pond says:

    Good – I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your website. I had no trouble navigating through all tabs as well as related info ended up being truly simple to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, web site theme . a tones way for your client to communicate. Excellent task.

  10. a1488592 says:

    I’ve said that least 1488592 times. SCK was here

  11. awesome. very interesting.. like your angle on it

  12. Anyone ever notice that in order for a white woman to be deemed as gorgeous, her body first has to resemble the voluptuous curves of latinas? or black women?

  13. Tom Harwood says:

    I simply wanted to construct a quick message to be able to express gratitude to you for all the lovely solutions you are giving here. My time intensive internet research has now been compensated with awesome details to share with my pals. I ‘d admit that we site visitors actually are definitely endowed to exist in a fine website with so many marvellous individuals with great basics. I feel very privileged to have discovered the webpages and look forward to tons of more amazing moments reading here. Thank you once more for all the details.

  14. sofeduc site says:

    Wohh just what I was looking for, appreciate it for putting up. “Talent develops in tranquillity, character in the full current of human life.”

  15. Al Goolesby says:

    I am really impressed. Today I spent a lot of my mean calculate irritating to attain something attractive on this topic. To finish I set up your blog. Thankfulness for that!

  16. Cele mai bune ponturiu de promovare web

  17. Good – I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating through all tabs as well as related information ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or something, site theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Nice task.

  18. Zhu Hai city was dragged on the road has awoken little pale, cold sweat constantly run, do not know what happened, and so the taxi driver asked him to go some where frightened when he spake Go, go to the hospital I, my arm was reinforced prick Zhu Hai city considered a wise man, if that is the gunshot wound he estimated the driver would not dare pull up, pull security are not allowed even to the police station door pull the car keys and ran a man.

  19. Qiang said: such a big thing. Ambulance to soon, but I think we can leave here, otherwise there really is brought into the Public Security Bureau is the mouth can not tell, you still need people to plant there hard to deal with it.

  20. Save All Paperwork: Whatever paperwork arrives with your parts or which is provided from the seller
    should be maintained. It won’t take you extremely long to work out what way to employ it. You wont get a true imitation of your signature with this Android app, unless you can cleverly manipulate the mechanics behind its operation, but that is highly unlikely.

  21. All they need to do is to enroll with their name, email, contact number
    and country and vemmabuilder will cater to the particular country of the person.
    Wouldn’t it be easier if we could be able to save changes ourselves whenever we want. Therefore it’s better to always
    do the intelligent point and take these tips.

  22. katalog says:

    I am going to instantly get your own rss feed as I can’t in locating your current email membership url and also newsletter program. Conduct you’ve any? Please i want to comprehend to make sure that I might simply sign up. Many thanks.

  23. homepage says:

    This allows the website to be more attractive and catchy.
    s why most web master prefers using this builder
    for designing and developing their web form. Maybe you should
    look into thick bar training, it’s proven
    to be healthier and its used by bodybuilders, NFL teams and even the Special Forces.

  24. Thank you so much for bringing this to our attention. This is a very informative article with a lot of information, great content!

  25. Daren Verry says:

    I needed to compose you this little observation to be able to give thanks yet again for your stunning concepts you have provided on this page. It has been simply tremendously generous with people like you to convey unhampered exactly what most people would’ve distributed for an e book to get some cash on their own, certainly seeing that you might well have tried it if you considered necessary. Those techniques likewise served as the good way to fully grasp other people online have similar dream the same as my own to know the truth whole lot more in regard to this problem. I believe there are several more pleasurable times in the future for individuals who view your site. Readmore: Bạn đã biết sử dụng máy làm đá viên đúng cách?

  26. Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your blog. You have some really good posts and I think I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please shoot me an email if interested. Many thanks! Please take a look this: Lựa chọn rèm cửa sổ đẹp cho căn hộ bạn

  27. Since chicken coop kits are available and also several distinct sizes and shapes you’ll want to think
    about the reason for your own coop. One of the machine’s best
    features is its motor which is thermally protected to
    prevent overheating

  28. Good article. Ive just forwarded the link to my buddy|.

Leave a Reply